Thursday, February 26, 2009

Ishmael blog post 1



1. Two ways to identify people from our culture are through our way of keeping food under lock and key, and identifying ourselves as fundamentally flawed. Ishmael says that people all over the world are of the same culture, and I agree with him. The kind of culture that Ishmael is talking about is the culture of agriculture, which is what seperates us from animals. The majority of the world are takers while very few remain as leavers.
2. Ishmael says that humans are inheritly flawed, and I disagree. I feel that Humans are not inherently flawed. But our culture is. The leavers were not really flawed, but when we expanded to something we didn't really know by becoming takers. We did not know how to make a civilization and were then destined to fail. One can not try to expand onto a failed experiment without scrapping it and starting over. The leavers were going along perfectly fine before the takers came. Humans are not inherently flawed, just takers are.
3. Leavers are those who didn't take up agriculture while the takers were practiced and picked up agriculture as their way to survive and formed a civilization. Americans are what are known as takers. We are completely based on the beliefs of the takers, and thus also believe ourselves as fundamentally flawed and destined to fail without trying to save ourselves. We feel that the only way to find a way to live sustainably is to find a different race to show us the way and save us.

5 comments:

Anthony Robles said...

I like your reference to the text that reminds me of when this happened and makes your claims more believable

Dominic said...

wow, it's really nice to see that you disagree with ishmael about humans being flawed. i thought you made a great argument supporting your case, and it was really clever of you to say that the culture, not humas are flawed!

alex said...

Wow, your story was interesting.

Adrian Trevizo said...

i like how you back up your statement when you said that humans were not flawed but our culture is.

sonorukle said...

ok i really like your answers but doesn't Mother Culture say that we are inherited flawed. well and i totally agree with you on the last question